Oct 07, 2016 the correlation between knuckle cracking and arthritis is due to chance alone. Arthritis is a common condition affecting around 10 million people in the uk it causes pain and inflammation in a joint most commonly joints in the hands, spine, knees and hips. No one can definitively say that cracking knuckles causes arthritis. Currently theres no substantial evidence that shows knuckle cracking leads to arthritis. Cracking your knuckles throughout your lifetime will eventually cause you to have arthritis. As most of us who did it can attest, sooner or later you will encounter someone who gives you the dire warnings that, one day, all your knuckle cracking will result in agonising arthritis. The truth and the myth behind the cracking knuckles debate. Where did the myth knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Your knucklecracking habit might be an annoyance to those around you, but popping the joints in your fingers will not harm your health. This causes gas bubbles in the joint fluid to collapse or burst. In fact, studies have shown no difference in the prevalence of arthritis between those who crack and do not crack their knuckles.
There have been a few studies over the years that considered whether or not cracking knuckles caused arthritis. Mom always said, stop cracking those knuckles or youll end up giving yourself arthritis. May 18, 2019 study conclusions on whether knuckle cracking causes arthritis. When each group was asked about knucklecracking habits, it actually turned out that those who didnt crack their knuckles had slightly greater rates of. Can cracking your knuckles cause cartilage breakdown. Good news about knuckle cracking, donald unger published a study in 1998 to see if knuckle cracking really causes arthritis. No doubt youve been told this a million or so times.
Arthritis and cracking knuckles the reason people associate knuckle cracking with arthritis because it makes a cracking noise and, if something cracks, it must be being damaged. Sep 10, 2007 there is no evidence that cracking knuckles causes any damage such as arthritis in the joints. As most of us who did it can attest, sooner or later you will encounter someone who gives you the dire warnings that, one day, all your knucklecracking will result in agonising arthritis. The urban myth of knucklecracking and arthritis anyone whos old enough to remember a time before the internet can appreciate that we now live in a brave and strange new world of information overload.
This is one of those quasimedical issues that is scarcely mentioned in. Knuckle cracking has not been shown to be harmful or beneficial. Fortunately for knuckle cracking haters, it takes a while for the gases to reenter the solution, during which time the characteristic noises cant be made. Although cracking your knuckles has not been shown to explicitly cause arthritis, that doesnt mean that it is completely without consequences. Knuckle cracking myth musculoskeletal issues articles. So its often thought that if you engage in repetitive activity and put added stress on.
Heres what really happens when you crack your knuckles, and why its not as bad as you may think. Busting the myth about knuckle cracking chicago health. Study conclusions on whether knuckle cracking causes arthritis. May 30, 2012 when each group was asked about knuckle cracking habits, it actually turned out that those who didnt crack their knuckles had slightly greater rates of arthritis 18. Knuckle cracking is a common behavior enjoyed by many. Knuckles are the joints between your fingers and your hands. This wouldnt mean that the knuckle cracking directly causes the swelling or weakness, it would be due to the confounding variable such as their occupations. An orthopedic hand surgeon explains what makes knuckles crack and what researchers know about how. As for the crack or pop noise you hear after you crack your knuckles, its not bad either although it may annoy the people around you.
You may still be wondering where the idea of arthritis being linked to knuckle cracking originated. Thats good news if you like to crack your knuckles, but its bad news for those of us who cant stand it when you do it. However, knuckle cracking may be associated with tendon and other soft tissue problems. Most people crack their knuckles to make their joints feel loose. The correlation between knuckle cracking and arthritis is due to chance alone. People are often grossed out by knuckle cracking, but studies have proven that it doesnt cause long term damage or arthritis and could actually be good for you. Advertisement arthritis specifically osteoarthritis is the degeneration of cartilage, which is the spongy cushion between bones in a joint.
More specifically, knuckle cracking does not cause arthritis. Bottom line knuckle popping does not cause arthritis. Knuckles are lubricated by synovial fluid, a yolklike substance that reduces friction between the bones, easing movement. Simply put, arthritis is inflammation in joints and surrounding tissue that causes pain and debilitation. One california doctor deserves snaps for his 60year experiment to determine if his mothers warnings that knuckle cracking leads to arthritis were. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis 9 medical myths.
Sep 11, 2015 a number of studies have been done over the years to find out the longterm impact of cracking your knuckles. For years, patients have told me that their mothers and grandmothers have warned them not to crack their knuckles because it causes arthritis down the road. Conventional wisdom says cracking knuckles does cause problems, but a researcher who studied the question says no. Knuckle cracking, damp weather, nightshade foods and more. Our parents more than likely told us to stop doing it because of its irritating sounds. Thats the conclusion of several studies that compared rates of hand arthritis among habitual knuckle crackers and people who didnt crack their knuckles. Have you ever cracked your knuckles and had someone yell at you to stop because it causes arthritis. In general form, it is the inflammation of your joints that is caused due to various reasons including autoimmune problems, bacterial infection, or stds. Many people crack their knuckles out of nervous habit, or to annoy those who tell them to stop because it will give them arthritis. There is no medical evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis.
There is no evidence that cracking knuckles causes any damage such as arthritis in the joints. Arthritis in the hands can cause a crackling type of sound. Debbie yi, an emergency medicine and neurology physician at the hospital of upenn says. The authors say this means knucklecracking should be discouraged, but i wonder whether the people who crack their knuckles might feel more discomfort in their hands in the first place. Fun fact once you crack your knuckles, it takes about 25 to 30 minutes for the gases to redissolve into the joint fluid.
What causes arthritis cracking knuckles rheumatoid. May 20, 2015 although cracking your knuckles has not been shown to explicitly cause arthritis, that doesnt mean that it is completely without consequences. Urban legend would indicate that knuckle cracking leads to arthritis of the joints of the hand. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis 10 old wives. Cracking your knuckles may aggravate the people around you, but it probably wont raise your risk for arthritis. Sep 25, 2016 professor conaghan, a spokesman for arthritis research uk, adds. Arthritis and cracking knuckles the reason people associate knucklecracking with arthritis because it makes a cracking noise and, if something cracks, it must be being damaged. In a time when medical science still was not developed enough to establish the cause and effect link between every minute action of the human body, corelating cracking of joints to arthritis and other painful joint conditions was an easy. When you crack your knuckles, you are pulling apart two bones at the joint, which means the synovial fluid has to fill more space. Knuckle cracking, damp weather, nightshade foods and more arthritis myths dispelled as the arthritis is so common medical problem affecting millions of people around the world, it is not surprising that a number of myths that appeared many of us have come to regard as the real facts. Joint cracking can result from a negative pressure pulling nitrogen gas temporarily into the joint, such as when knuckles are cracked. In fact, many highly respected medical facilities and sources, including harvard and the johns hopkins arthritis center, have come out definitely stating that joint cracking doesnt cause arthritis. Jun 21, 2018 the cracking of knuckle cracking seems to be produced by increasing the space between finger joints. Nowadays, the causes of arthritis are better understoodjoint.
It can become a habit or a way to deal with nervous energy. Mar 08, 2019 the department of orthopedics noted there is no evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis. There are no definitive links between knuckle cracking and arthritis or any. Fortunately for knucklecracking haters, it takes a while for the gases to reenter the solution, during which time the characteristic noises cant be made. Scientists actually looked into it and found no evidence that habitual knucklecrackers were at an increased risk of developing hand oa. Apr 21, 2017 knuckle cracking doesnt cause arthritis, but some research suggests the habit may not be completely harmless. These joints are surrounded and lubricated by synovial fluid, a thick, clear liquid.
You can hear more medical myths on health check on the bbc world service. Orthopedic myths knuckle cracking, surgery misconceptions. Jan 21, 2017 its hard to truly tell where most myths originate, but it may have to do with arthritis sufferers noticing their joints cracking. One myth that exists states that repeated knuckle cracking will lead to arthritis. According to steve mirsky, author of crack research. Top myths about back cracking canary wharf chiropractor.
But does habitual knuckle cracking cause any longterm effects or worse yet arthritis. Another idea to consider would be the idea of reverse causation meaning that arthritis and swelling of. However, repeatedly cracking your knuckles may cause temporary soreness of the joint. Kids think its cool to hear that popping and crackling sound that emanates from their joints when they bend and twist them. Some people crack their knuckles by pulling the tip of each finger one at.
Get more health and wellness tips from living better. The fascination with knuckle cracking often starts at an early age. Thats the conclusion of several studies that compared rates of hand arthritis among habitual knucklecrackers and people who didnt crack their knuckles. A number of studies have been done over the years to find out the longterm impact of cracking your knuckles. Thanks to dr donald unger md, this medical chestnut has a definitive. It would be a gross overstatement, however, to say that the medical literature has thoroughly explored this connection. However, over 100 conditions fall under the scope of arthritis and discerning facts from myths about the symptoms, treatments and environmental factors that trigger pain can be daunting. Thats right or at the very least plausible that youve had it backwards all these years. Arthritis causes knuckle cracking, not the other way around. Professor conaghan, a spokesman for arthritis research uk, adds. Dr unger reported that he had been cracking the knuckles on his left hand at least twice daily over a 50year period, while the right hand was never cracked and used as a control.
Knuckle cracking doesnt really have anything to do with friction between joints, which is the common misunderstandinginstead, the popping sound comes from gas bubbles in. He cracked his left knuckles in his hand twice a day for fifty years. The truth behind 6 arthritis myths expert tips and. People keep telling me to stop cracking my knuckles. However, a couple of reports in the medical literature are available associating knuckle cracking with injury of the ligaments surrounding the joint or dislocation of the tendons attachments of muscles to bones which improved with conservative.
The authors say this means knuckle cracking should be discouraged, but i wonder whether the people who crack their knuckles might feel more discomfort in their hands in the first place. Osteoarthritis oa, sometimes called wear and tear arthritis, occurs when the cartilage or cushion between joints breaks down leading to pain, stiffness and swelling. Knuckle cracking doesnt really have anything to do with friction between joints, which is the common misunderstandinginstead, the popping sound comes from gas bubbles in the fluid that cushions the finger bones. The noise of cracking or popping in our joints is actually nitrogen bubbles bursting in our synovial fluid. Cracking knuckles or fingers is something most of us learn to do when we are younger. The truth and the myth behind the cracking knuckles debate cracking your knuckles may aggravate the people around you, but it probably wont raise your risk for arthritis. Cracking of joints does not cause arthritis hearing your joints let out a loud pop can be a tad unsettling. Certain myths as to the potential sideeffects of cracking ones knuckles have sprung up over the years, and this article will now examine the truth, if any, behind these myths. Despite warnings from your grandparents that youll suffer a life of arthritis if you sit around cracking your knuckles, this myth is busted. For most others, cracking the knuckles is merely an indulgence or a habit. The movement of ligaments around the joint can also cause a popping sound. More than 100 different types of arthritis are known by far. Cracking your knuckles causes arthritis the knuckles are the joints between the fingers and hand, and these joints contain a lubricant called synovial fluid. The widespread notion that cracking your knuckles causes arthritis or makes your finger joints bigger is a myth.
If a joint gets locked when it pops, knuckle cracking could lead to injuries in. To set the record straight, weve listed 10 of the most common myths about the human body. For our october 2011 issue, we asked dimitrios pappas, md, assistant professor of medicine at columbia. This is an old wives tale that has been passed around for decades, however there is no evidence to support it. Cracking your knuckles leads to arthritis andor makes it worse. It is virtually impossible to monitor a group of people long enough and sufficiently control their environment in order to definitively say whether or not knuckle cracking causes arthritis. Aug 03, 2019 more than 100 different types of arthritis are known by far. Its hard to truly tell where most myths originate, but it may have to do with arthritis. Knuckle cracking doesnt cause arthritis, but some research suggests the habit may not be completely harmless. As for the crack or pop noise you hear after you crack your knuckles, its not bad. Understanding what physically occurs when you crack your knuckles will help you realize that the knuckle cracking causes arthritis theory is actually just a popular myth. While joint popping may not cause arthritis, it is not completely riskfree.
Its a bit like blowing up a balloon and then stretching the walls of the balloon outward until it pops. Sometimes knucklecrackers can go too far and the resulting pop is actually the sound of a dislocated joint or broken bone. D who works with our doctors online partners at edocamerica. Some get hooked and form a habit of cracking knuckles on a frequent basis. One study found that there was no increase of hand arthritis among knuckle crackers, however, knuckle cracking was related to hand swelling and lower grip strength. Arthritis is a common ailment affecting millions, and myths such as whether cracking knuckles causes it lead to confusion and can get in the way of effectively dealing with arthritis. The department of orthopedics noted there is no evidence that knuckle cracking causes arthritis.
1076 201 607 430 1203 1523 366 1386 891 1118 126 1644 1548 1316 959 729 1109 478 604 995 650 683 1020 1504 317 1237 1411 1467 350 618 304 1097